A trend some may not be aware of.

General discussions of forests and trees that do not focus on a specific species or specific location.

Moderators: edfrank, dbhguru

User avatar
Lucas
Posts: 837
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 11:55 am

A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Lucas » Sat Dec 31, 2016 3:00 pm


Click on image to see its original size

Can Hinge-cutting Have Potential Negatives Effects on Your Forest?

http://ents-bbs.org/viewtopic.php?f=201 ... =30#p36923

http://mecostacd.org/2016/04/can-hinge- ... ur-forest/

Let me begin by saying, I love my deer and deer hunting as much as anyone out there. Just like many of you, I plan my vacations around the deer hunting seasons. “Deer talk” isn’t just something that happens during “the” season. It is a part of life year round in my camp. My passion for all things outdoors, lead me to choose a career in natural resource management where I have been a forester for nearly 34 years now.
For the past 28+ years, I have been a public service forester administering the Forestry Assistance Program (FAP) for the Osceola-Lake and Mecosta Conservation Districts. The primary target of this state funded service is the private landowners who collectively own nearly 90% of the land base found in my service area. The principal goal of the service is to help the private landowner to make informed decisions about the management of the natural resources found on their property.
My favorite part of the job is meeting onsite with private landowners. It’s during these one-on-one site visits that I’m able to assess the needs of the property relative to the landowner’s goals and objectives. It shouldn’t come as any big surprise that more management decisions on private lands are made with wildlife habitat goals in mind than for any other reason. The wildlife species most revered, is the white-tail deer.
For some time now, while conducting site visits, I have been encountering a tremendous increase in the utilization of hinge-cutting techniques aimed at enhancing deer habitat. Some applications appear to hit the mark quite nicely. Yet others, are starting to raise a bit of concern. While I’m not the biggest advocate of the practice, I’m certainly not opposed to its use. With a well thought out plan, it can be an effective, short-term fix to a necessary deer habitat component that is lacking in many private forests. hinge6 RO
However, setting my wildlife passions aside, the forester in me, is starting to ask, has the hinge-cutting “craze” gotten out of hand? Are there potential long-lasting consequences to the future health, productivity and sustainability of certain private forestlands that are being over-looked? Are there other alternatives to managing the forest resource that better serve the wildlife resource? Should private forest owners be asking these same questions before they set their actions in motion? At this point in time, I would answer yes to each of these questions.
As many of you will already know, the term “hinge cut” refers to cutting partially through a small tree by only applying a back-cut so that it can be tipped over, yet the tree remains attached to the stump and alive for a period of time. The technique is commonly applied to accomplish three objectives: 1) create instant hiding places where deer will bed; 2) provide a source of browse in two forms…first from the hinged tree itself and secondly from the new shoots and forage that spring up once sunlight is allowed in; 3) and strategically felling trees to funnel deer past a desired ambush location.
I have utilized the practice on my own property albeit on a small scale basis. Applying hinge-cutting techniques to cull trees (undesirable species and those of poor form) will increase deer cover, browse and improve the overall health and quality of the forest. Smaller trees generally are more conducive to hinging and far less dangerous to cut and tip over. Some tree species are better suited to hinging than others as well.
The strongest argument against hinge cutting is human safety (hinge-cutting seriously violates the basic rules for chainsaw safety while safely felling a tree). I get that and I hope you do as well. I grew up in a family of loggers and know all too well the harm a chainsaw can cause in the blink of an eye.
A chainsaw is arguably the most dangerous hand-tool known to mankind. Yet it can be purchased without any proof of qualifications or certification. According to Chuck Oslund, a Professional Chainsaw Safety Systems instructor, a chainsaw operating with a chain speed of 50 mph will send 500 uncovered teeth per second a few inches distance from your leg (or in the case of hinge-cutting, mere inches from your face). Think about that! If you learn to operate a chainsaw properly and maintain it in good working condition, it can make easier work of getting many forestry, agriculture and homeowner jobs done with greater efficiency and exactness. If you use it incorrectly, haphazardly or casually, it can become a powerful, forceful tool capable of doing great bodily harm.
In addition to safety concerns, some natural resource professionals (myself included) are beginning to raise questions about the long term impacts on forested sites where the over-aggressive application of hinge-cutting has taken place. Among those concerns, are sites where rapid invasion of undesirable shrubs such as autumn olive, honeysuckle, Japanese barberry, buckthorn, and others are out-competing native flora. Over a period of time, invasives can completely displace native vegetation and seriously run the risk of compromising the long-term health and ecological functionality of the forest.
On sites where red oak is present, additional concerns are raised for the potential introduction of oak wilt. Oak wilt disease is spread between trees through roots, by beetles, and by the movement of firewood. The critical DO NOT prune period to lessen chances of introducing oak wilt is April 15 through July 15. While most landowners won’t be including red oaks in their hinge-cutting activities, some already are. Even an accidental injury to a red oak during the felling process while hinge-cutting will create a potential open invitation to oak wilt.
Aspen is another tree species that every deer habitat enhancement enthusiast should take note of. If it appears on your property, you will be making the best long-term investment in enhancing your deer habitat by regenerating and expanding its presence where possible on your property. If aspen is a minor component species found amongst other tree species, you risk losing it if it is cut incorrectly; i.e. you fail to provide the full sunlight condition needed for sprout survival. Less aspen, less deer. You decide.
Furthermore, exposing some high-value hardwood species to full sunlight will likely
result in excessive sprouting on the clear limbless stems. This will vastly diminish their future value. Lastly, most landowners won’t be hinge-cutting high value tree, but again, some already are. The loss in current or potential future income can be quite significant if the wrong trees are sacrificed.
Participation in some state and federal programs requires the professional management of your forest resource. A state tax reduction program like the Qualified Forest Program (QFP) requires participants to professionally manage their forest resource according to a certified management plan. Hinge-cutting can be a practice to improve the overall health of the forest while meeting wildlife objectives for the property.
The problem arises when forest owners over-use hinge-cutting activities to the extent that careful control of the stand’s density is compromised to the extent that it affects current and future productivity of the stand. Although hinge-cutting can effectively play a role in eliminating identified cull trees in many timber types, removing too many of the wrong trees can result in an understocked forest. This could potentially lead to dismissal from the QFP tax reduction program.
Federal Farm Bill programs can also be applied for and utilized to enhance forest and wildlife habitat objectives. These financial incentive payments are provided with prior approval and implemented according to a participant’s certified management plan. Mis-use of forest stand improvement practices could potentially jeopardize incentive payments.
One of the best investments you can make for your property is to schedule an appointment with a natural resource professional to learn more about your forest. Not all sites are created equal, in terms of their potential. Seeking professional assistance will keep you working within the limits of the property and help you to avoid a hit and miss approach to your decision making.
Many forest management practices provide better long-term wildlife habitat enhancement benefits than hinge-cutting. In addition, many forest management practices have the potential to generate a source of revenue. And, where safety is an issue, they will be applied by experienced professional equipment operators.
At the current time, 49 counties are covered by the Forestry Assistance Program. When at full capacity, there are 20 public service foresters like myself available at no-cost to help private forest owners to make informed resource management decisions for their property. Make a visit to the Michigan Department of Agriculture and Rural Development website. Locate Privatelands Initiative and an interactive map to the FAP. If your property is located in a county not currently covered by the FAP, go to the Michigan Forest Association website at: http://www.michiganforests.com and click the MFA Foresters list; or go to http://www.michigan.gov/qfp or http://www.michigan.gov/foreststewardship to locate a professional forester near you.
Hinge-cutting can play a role in enhancing your deer habitat. But before you fire up the chainsaw, consider taking a chainsaw safety course; be sure you have the proper personal protective equipment recommended while operating a chainsaw and be sure to wear it; check your insurance policy; and lastly, visit with a professional forester to be sure you’re managing your forest resource not just cutting trees.
Posted on: April 5th, 2016 By Rick Lucas
Rick Lucas
Rick Lucas
Rick is the District Forester with the Mecosta Conservation District. He can be reached at rick.lucas@mi.nacdnet.net or (231) 510-8113.
We travel the Milky way together, trees and men. - John Muir

User avatar
dbhguru
Posts: 4487
Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2010 9:34 pm

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by dbhguru » Sat Dec 31, 2016 3:43 pm

Ents,

I was not aware of the trend. In New England, and elsewhere in the Northeast, there are far too many deer.

Bob
Robert T. Leverett
Co-founder, Native Native Tree Society
Co-founder and President
Friends of Mohawk Trail State Forest
Co-founder, National Cadre

User avatar
Lucas
Posts: 837
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 11:55 am

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Lucas » Sat Dec 31, 2016 7:41 pm

It is more about quality vs quantity.
We travel the Milky way together, trees and men. - John Muir

User avatar
dbhguru
Posts: 4487
Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2010 9:34 pm

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by dbhguru » Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:18 pm

Joe,

Reference Rick Lucas's detailed description of hing-cutting. Here in Massachusetts, I'm curious as to how hinge-cutting, as described, can be viewed favorably from the perspective of a managing forester unless the forest in question has been continuously high-graded, and well, looks like crap. Don't mean to sound prejudiced, but I have always been disapproving of the wildlife habitat over all view of a woodland.

How is hinge-cutting viewed by DCR?

Bob
Robert T. Leverett
Co-founder, Native Native Tree Society
Co-founder and President
Friends of Mohawk Trail State Forest
Co-founder, National Cadre

Joe

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Joe » Tue Jan 03, 2017 7:54 am

Bob, I know that Rick has been posting on the NTS site for a while but I didn't realize until now that he's a state district forester.

Outside this forum I've never heard of this practice and have never seen it here in Massachusetts. As Rick says, "Many forest management practices provide better long-term wildlife habitat enhancement benefits than hinge-cutting."

Maybe it does have some benefits but the only one I can think of is that the deer hunter will be able to focus his attention in the area with the hinged trees. So, it's not about more deer, but about more focused hunting. If 100 acres were properly thinned- that too would enhance deer habitat but then the deer might be anywhere in that 100 acres- but by hinging trees, the hunter can set up his deer stand right there- so it's a bit of a lazy technique.

If an owner does this on only a limited number of trees in his woodlot and finds success with it for that objective of deer hunting- so be it. I doubt this practice is ever done on public forests. I doubt any foresters in Mass. have ever heard of this practice- though maybe the few who are serious deer hunters may be aware of it from the literature.

If the hinged trees are the low value trees we'd like to thin out for silvicultural reasons- then maybe it can be seen as a cheap form of "timber stand improvement"- especially if the adjacent trees are healthy high value species needing to grow some more decades to produce high value timber.

In one of the videos in Lucas' message, a guy is standing under a tree that was back cut trying to pull it down. Looks pretty dangerous to me! It's a small tree but if landed on his head, it might kill him. Also, when hinging a tree, someone who doesn't really know how to cut trees is likely to have the hinge break in unanticipated ways which is very, very dangerous.

Joe

Joe

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Joe » Tue Jan 03, 2017 10:29 am

Another comment about safety and hinged trees. If you cut a tree without a box cut in the direction of the fall- as the tree starts to fall- it will often "jump" backward. I've seen this happen when I poorly cut some trees and my back cut missed the box cut. The entire tree will slide back towards you. Once a tree starts to fall- if not directed by the box cut- it can go in any direction. If you think it's going to where you want and you're not prepared- you might find the tree aiming for you. All this can happen very, very fast. So, my big problem with this practice is the safety problem- not the fact that it's ugly or possibly bad silviculture- or that there may be better ways to enhance wildlife.

I was once cutting a small spruce, not much bigger than a Christmas tree on a steep hillside. Since the tree was small and I thought it could only fall downhill, I didn't think I need a box cut in the direction of the fall so I just cut the uphill side- but it snapped prematurely and the tree- the freshely cut section of the stem came back towards me and hit my leg just above the knee. That cut section was only about 3" in diameter but it was like getting hit by a baseball bat. I limped around for a few weeks.
Joe

User avatar
Lucas
Posts: 837
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 11:55 am

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Lucas » Tue Jan 03, 2017 3:09 pm

We travel the Milky way together, trees and men. - John Muir

User avatar
Lucas
Posts: 837
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2014 11:55 am

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Lucas » Tue Jan 03, 2017 3:16 pm

Joe wrote: so it's a bit of a lazy technique. Joe
Easy, Joe, easy. Do not be quick to judge. It is not easy and a lot of these guys are doing good things for wildlife, including planting trees, like oaks, etc. Some of them are incredibly knowledgeable about ecology, soils, etc.

I came to this site due to my interest in oaks for deer. My biophilia kicked in and I have stayed.

http://habitat-talk.com/index.php

http://www.deerhunterforum.com/index.ph ... 5973/posts

2 sites with a lot on hinging
We travel the Milky way together, trees and men. - John Muir

wisconsitom
Posts: 181
Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 4:08 pm

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by wisconsitom » Fri Jan 06, 2017 9:30 am

The whole thing to aid a species.....that is already wildly out of control. No sense and all those guys and their oaks are not into forests. They are into mast crops for deer or turkey, that's about as far as their "ecological" concerns go. If a scrubby type of oak would provide those acorns, the whole Wiscosnin woods would be scrub. Wisconsin is full of these guys, their food plots spreading invasive species into the woods, the whole bit. No, I'm not impressed.

Joe

Re: A trend some may not be aware of.

Post by Joe » Fri Jan 06, 2017 12:37 pm

wisconsitom wrote:The whole thing to aid a species.....that is already wildly out of control. No sense and all those guys and their oaks are not into forests. They are into mast crops for deer or turkey, that's about as far as their "ecological" concerns go. If a scrubby type of oak would provide those acorns, the whole Wiscosnin woods would be scrub. Wisconsin is full of these guys, their food plots spreading invasive species into the woods, the whole bit. No, I'm not impressed.
Here in Mass., the state wildlife guys (serving mostly hunters actually) just ADORE clearcuts, especially really big ones. They've even convinced MA Audubon of the glories of huge clearcuts. I don't mind some modest sized clearcuts and I have no problem with hunters, though it's not my thing- but really big clearcuts in a heavily populated state like Mass., is bonkers.

I've never heard these wildlife guys call for protection of old growth and near old growth to turn into old growth- for the species that prefer mature forests. Strange, but I've had some hunters say to me, "Joe, you go deep into the woods without packing iron?". Not sure what they're afraid of. :)
Joe

Post Reply

Return to “General Discussions”