Guys,
The pith method will still result in some disagreements about a small number trees, The point to remember is that almost all of the really egregious examples of multitrunk trees will be weeded out if the pith method is accepted and used in a responsible manner. Maybe it is not perfect, but it is enormously better that the present situation.
Ed
Its time to play...Multi-trunk or Single-trunk! YOU decide.
Discussions of trees, forests, trip reports and site descriptions of other locations in Eastern United States, Canada, and Greenland.
Re: Its time to play...Multi-trunk or Single-trunk! YOU deci
Post by edfrank » Thu Oct 03, 2013 6:22 pm
"I love science and it pains me to think that so many are terrified of the subject or feel that choosing science means you cannot also choose compassion, or the arts, or be awe by nature. Science is not meant to cure us of mystery, but to reinvent and revigorate it." by Robert M. Sapolsky
Re: Its time to play...Multi-trunk or Single-trunk! YOU deci
Post by Don » Thu Oct 03, 2013 6:30 pm
Ed-
You're on the money...especially on these one view challenges. Will and Jess are exactly right, there are a number of Johnny's images that there just isn't enough views to make a good judgement.
If our current recommendations hold sway (a photo of the bottom 10' from each quadrant if possible), having four images to view will I think, bring about more consensus.
Now if Michael Taylor can work up a simple Structure from Motion program that 'rotates' the four image delineations through one revolution and seek a best fit, hmmm, I think we'd be getting close...
But yeah, what we seek will be immensely better than what we have had.
-Don
You're on the money...especially on these one view challenges. Will and Jess are exactly right, there are a number of Johnny's images that there just isn't enough views to make a good judgement.
If our current recommendations hold sway (a photo of the bottom 10' from each quadrant if possible), having four images to view will I think, bring about more consensus.
Now if Michael Taylor can work up a simple Structure from Motion program that 'rotates' the four image delineations through one revolution and seek a best fit, hmmm, I think we'd be getting close...
But yeah, what we seek will be immensely better than what we have had.
-Don
Don Bertolette - President/Moderator, WNTS BBS
Restoration Forester (Retired)
Science Center
Grand Canyon National Park
BJCP Apprentice Beer Judge
View my Alaska Big Tree List Webpage at:
http://www.akbigtreelist.org
Restoration Forester (Retired)
Science Center
Grand Canyon National Park
BJCP Apprentice Beer Judge
View my Alaska Big Tree List Webpage at:
http://www.akbigtreelist.org
Return to “Eastern United States, Canada, and Greenland”
Jump to
- About Us: Native Tree Society
- ↳ Organizational Information
- ↳ Native Tree Society
- ↳ Eastern Native Tree Society
- ↳ Western Native Tree Society
- ↳ Post Here First - Introduce Yourself
- Measurement
- ↳ Measurement and Dendromorphometry
- ↳ Tree Measurement Videos
- ↳ Tree Measuring Guidelines
- ↳ Dendromorphometry Toolkit
- Trip Reports and Site Descriptions
- ↳ Eastern United States, Canada, and Greenland
- ↳ Discussions of the Eastern United States and Canada
- ↳ Alabama
- ↳ Arkansas
- ↳ Connecticut
- ↳ Delaware
- ↳ Florida
- ↳ Georgia
- ↳ Greenland
- ↳ Great Smoky Mountains National Park
- ↳ Illinois
- ↳ Indiana
- ↳ Iowa
- ↳ Kentucky
- ↳ Louisiana
- ↳ Maine
- ↳ Maryland
- ↳ Massachusetts
- ↳ MA - Mohawk Trail State Forest
- ↳ Michigan
- ↳ Minnesota
- ↳ Mississippi
- ↳ Missouri
- ↳ New Brunswick
- ↳ Newfoundland & Labrador
- ↳ New Hampshire
- ↳ New Jersey
- ↳ New York
- ↳ North Carolina
- ↳ Nova Scotia
- ↳ Ohio
- ↳ Ontario
- ↳ Pennsylvania
- ↳ PA - Cook Forest SP
- ↳ PA Great Lakes Region
- ↳ North Central PA - PA Wilds
- ↳ Northeast Pennsylvania Mountains
- ↳ Phildelphia and the Countryside
- ↳ Alleghenies and Ridge and Valley Areas
- ↳ Dutch Country - South Central
- ↳ Pittsburgh and Southwestern PA
- ↳ Prince Edward Island
- ↳ Quebec
- ↳ Rhode Island
- ↳ South Carolina
- ↳ Tennessee
- ↳ Vermont
- ↳ Virginia
- ↳ Washington DC
- ↳ West Virginia
- ↳ Wisconsin
- ↳ Western United States and Canada
- ↳ Western North America - General Discussions
- ↳ Boreal Forest
- ↳ Alaska
- ↳ Alberta
- ↳ Arizona
- ↳ British Columbia
- ↳ California
- ↳ Colorado
- ↳ Hawaii
- ↳ Idaho
- ↳ Kansas
- ↳ Manitoba
- ↳ Montana
- ↳ Nebraska
- ↳ Nevada
- ↳ New Mexico
- ↳ North Dakota
- ↳ Northwest Territories
- ↳ Nunavut
- ↳ Oklahoma
- ↳ Oregon
- ↳ Saskatchewan
- ↳ South Dakota
- ↳ Texas
- ↳ Utah
- ↳ Washington
- ↳ Wyoming
- ↳ Yukon Territories
- ↳ Europe and the British Isles
- ↳ Europe and the British Isles - Overviews
- ↳ Weblinks for European Forests
- ↳ Balkans Expedition 2012 (to the region of former Yugoslavia)
- ↳ Belgium
- ↳ Bosnia & Herzegovina
- ↳ Croatia
- ↳ Estonia
- ↳ Finland
- ↳ France
- ↳ Georgia
- ↳ Great Britain
- ↳ Germany
- ↳ Hungary
- ↳ Iceland
- ↳ Ireland
- ↳ Italy
- ↳ Montenegro
- ↳ Netherlands
- ↳ Norway
- ↳ Poland
- ↳ Portugal
- ↳ Romania
- ↳ Russia
- ↳ Slovenia
- ↳ Slovakia
- ↳ Spain
- ↳ Sweden
- ↳ Ukraine
- ↳ Other Locations Around the World
- ↳ Africa
- ↳ Antarctica
- ↳ Asia
- ↳ Australia and New Zealand
- ↳ Central America, the Caribbean, and Mexico Locations
- ↳ Mexico
- ↳ Central America
- ↳ Caribbean Islands
- ↳ Discussions of the Caribbean Islands
- ↳ Puerto Rico
- ↳ Bermuda
- ↳ Middle Eastern Trees and Forests
- ↳ Polynesia, Micronesia, and Melanesia
- ↳ South America
- ↳ Southeast Asia & East Indies
- Discussion Forums
- ↳ Science Forums
- ↳ General Science Discussions
- ↳ Autopoietic Forest
- ↳ Canopy Research
- ↳ Fungi and Mycology
- ↳ Forest Ecology and Processes
- ↳ Invasive Species and Tree Diseases
- ↳ Multitrunk Trees, Woody Vines, and Other Forms
- ↳ Non-forested Ecosystems
- ↳ Old Growth and Primary Forests
- ↳ Remote Sensing, LIDAR, and GIS
- ↳ Unusual Forests
- ↳ Weather and Climate
- ↳ Trees and Forests - General Discussion Forums
- ↳ General Discussions
- ↳ NTS Members in the News
- ↳ Off-topic - Post About Anything Here
- ↳ Arborglyphs and Tree Carvings
- ↳ Arboriculture and Landscaping
- ↳ Biomass
- ↳ Bonsai Trees
- ↳ Books, Articles, and Internet References
- ↳ Computers, Smart Phones, Internet Media, & Software
- ↳ Children and Teens: Nature Activities and Education
- ↳ Fall Foliage
- ↳ NTS Facebook Group and Page
- ↳ Native Tree Society Facebook Group
- ↳ Forest Preservation and Conservation
- ↳ Forest Fires
- ↳ Forest Management
- ↳ Games, Contests, Quizzes, and Humor
- ↳ History and Historical Great Trees
- ↳ Glossary
- ↳ Indigenous Peoples
- ↳ Spring Awakenings - Phenology
- ↳ Special Places
- ↳ Tree Climbing
- ↳ General Tree Climbing Discussions
- ↳ Tree Climbing Tips, Techniques, and Equipment
- ↳ Tree Climbs
- ↳ Tree Species, Families and Identification
- ↳ Urban Forests, Trees, and Landscapes
- ↳ Wildlife and Wildlife Encounters
- ↳ Art, Aesthetics, and Humanities
- ↳ Art: General Discussions and Philosophy
- ↳ Art: Literature, Poetry, and Prose
- ↳ Art: Mixed Media. Other Forms, and Unclassified
- ↳ Art: Music and Song
- ↳ Art: Painting, Drawing, and Graphics
- ↳ Art: Sculpture
- ↳ Art and Science
- ↳ Forest Aesthetics
- ↳ Forest Experiences, Epiphanies, and Philosophies
- ↳ Leverett's Lounge
- ↳ 2010 Western Trip
- ↳ Photography Techniques
- ↳ Photography
- ↳ Religion, Myths, Legends, and Sacred Stories
- ↳ General Discussions on Religion
- ↳ Christianity
- ↳ Classical Mythology
- ↳ Druidism
- ↳ Forests Spritis and the Fey
- ↳ Legends
- ↳ Sacred Stories
- ↳ Dreams
- ↳ Scientists, Artists, and Naturalists
- ↳ Sounds of Nature
- ↳ Unclassified Aesthetics Discussions
- ↳ Value of Nature: Relationships Between People and the Forest
- ↳ Videos, Movies, and Televison Featuring Forests and Trees
- ↳ Video Production
- ↳ Woodcrafts
- ↳ Dendrochronology
- ↳ Dendrochronology and Tree Ages
- NTS Publications
- ↳ Bulletin of the Eastern Native Tree Society
- ↳ Buletin of ENTS - NTS Website Link
- ↳ eNTS Magazine
- ↳ eNTS Magazine NTS Website Link
- ↳ Special Publications
- ↳ Special Publications NTS Website Link - Reports 1 through 9
- General Information
- ↳ Projects and Surveys, Database, Groups, and Links
- ↳ Current Research Project Listings
- ↳ Adirondack Park, NY
- ↳ Allegheny River Corridor
- ↳ American Chestnut Project
- ↳ Big Tree Listings
- ↳ Blue Ridge Parkway Project
- ↳ Liriodendron Height Project - Neil Pederson
- ↳ Liriodendron Project
- ↳ Live Oak Project
- ↳ Montpelier Estate, VA
- ↳ Poplar Forest Project
- ↳ Tree Measurement Video
- ↳ Other Projects
- ↳ Lake Ontario - St. Lawrence Lowlands Tree Survey
- ↳ Trees Database
- ↳ Tree Database Website
- ↳ Database Discussions on NTS Website
- ↳ Native Tree Society Groups
- ↳ Executive Committee
- ↳ Scientific Advisory Board
- ↳ Arts, Aesthetics, and New Media Group
- ↳ Canopy Research Group
- ↳ Dendrochronology and Old Growth Forest Group
- ↳ Dendromorphometry Group
- ↳ Forest Ecology and Processes Group
- ↳ Forestry and Arboriculture Group
- ↳ Internet, Database, and Web Communications Group
- ↳ LiDAR and Computer Modeling Group
- ↳ Measurement and Exploration Group
- ↳ Multinational Coordination Group
- ↳ Tree Climbing and Recreational Activities Group
- ↳ Links to Other Tree Groups
- ↳ Special Lists
- ↳ Special Lists
- ↳ Tree of the Week
- ↳ Events and Gatherings
- ↳ Events 2014
- ↳ Events 2013
- ↳ Events 2012
- ↳ Events 2011
- ↳ Events 2010
- ↳ HCC Forest Summit 6/ENTS Rendezvous 2010
- ↳ WNTS Rendezvous July 2010
- ↳ Non- Events
- ↳ Events - Older
- ↳ BBS Administration - How Everything Works
- ↳ Terms of Usage
- ↳ Bulletin of ENTS, No. 10, Vol. 1, 2015
- ↳ eNTS Magazine 2016